Featured Pathways

More pathways

The Science of Climate Change

Climate change is no longer a distant threat or just a possibility, it is now a reality for all of us. In this pathway, Kevin Trenberth, a renowned climatologist, delves into the science behind climate change. He first introduces the climate system, its main components and forces.

Tackling the Plastic Crisis

Plastic pollution is by far the biggest threat to our oceans and this remains an incredibly tough problem to solve. Plastic credits could potentially serve as one of the much needed solutions for this crisis.

More pathways

Book a demo

Pricing

Ready to get started?

Plans & Membership

Our Platform

Expert led content

+1,000 expert presented, on-demand video modules

Learning analytics

Keep track of learning progress with our comprehensive data

Interactive learning

Engage with our video hotspots and knowledge check-ins

Testing & certification

Gain CPD / CPE credits and professional certification

Managed learning

Build, scale and manage your organisation’s learning

Integrations

Connect Sustainability Unlocked to your current platform

Featured Content

More featured content

The Scale of the Net Zero Challenge

The price of meeting net zero is estimated to be between $100-150 trillion over the next 30 years. Regardless of this cost, we need to reach net zero before climate change does irreversible damage to the environment and the economy.

ESG, Sustainability and Impact Jargon Buster

ESG, sustainability, impact… they all just mean green, right? Not quite. Despite being used often interchangeably, there are distinct differences between these terms.

More featured content

Book a demo

Pricing

Ready to get started?

Featured Pathways

More pathways

The Science of Climate Change

Climate change is no longer a distant threat or just a possibility, it is now a reality for all of us. In this pathway, Kevin Trenberth, a renowned climatologist, delves into the science behind climate change. He first introduces the climate system, its main components and forces.

Tackling the Plastic Crisis

Plastic pollution is by far the biggest threat to our oceans and this remains an incredibly tough problem to solve. Plastic credits could potentially serve as one of the much needed solutions for this crisis.

More pathways

Book a demo

Pricing

Ready to get started?

Plans & Membership

Our Platform

Expert led content

+1,000 expert presented, on-demand video modules

Learning analytics

Keep track of learning progress with our comprehensive data

Interactive learning

Engage with our video hotspots and knowledge check-ins

Testing & certification

Gain CPD / CPE credits and professional certification

Managed learning

Build, scale and manage your organisation’s learning

Integrations

Connect Sustainability Unlocked to your current platform

Featured Content

More featured content

The Scale of the Net Zero Challenge

The price of meeting net zero is estimated to be between $100-150 trillion over the next 30 years. Regardless of this cost, we need to reach net zero before climate change does irreversible damage to the environment and the economy.

ESG, Sustainability and Impact Jargon Buster

ESG, sustainability, impact… they all just mean green, right? Not quite. Despite being used often interchangeably, there are distinct differences between these terms.

More featured content

Book a demo

Pricing

Ready to get started?

Book a demo

Pricing

Ready to get started?

Navigating green claims without greenwashing
Greenwashing
10 mins to read

Navigating green claims without greenwashing

CMS

How should companies in the re-commerce sector state their environmental claims?

Navigating green claims without greenwashing

Start free trial

Unlock access to all content by signing up to a 7-day free trial

Online second-hand retail is on the rise, with increasingly eco-conscious consumers considering how they can shop more sustainably to reduce their fashion footprint. The Ethical Consumer and The Co-operative Bank’s 2023 Ethical Markets report recorded a 15% increase in people buying second-hand clothes for environmental reasons. Accordingly, “green” and “sustainable” claims have fast become a hot topic for companies looking to demonstrate their green credentials. As we noted in our previous article here, however, these same claims have also attracted the attention of government regulators and campaigners, scrutinising misleading or unsubstantiated claims.

In this article we summarise what operators in the re-commerce sector (from peer-to-peer platforms, to B2C resale retailers, and fulfilment providers) need to consider when illustrating their commitment to the cause.

What are “green claims”?

According to the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), the UK’s consumer regulator, a green claim is one that suggests that a product, service, process, or business is better (or less harmful) for the environment. The CMA notes that this can be demonstrated through statements, but also symbols, colours and product brand names.

In the UK, green claims are regulated through a combination of self-regulatory codes, and consumer protection legislation by way of the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations (CPUT) (soon to be restated – in substantially similar, but not identical form – under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act). In September 2021, the CMA published a new Green Claims Code to help businesses understand and comply with their obligations under consumer protection law when making environmental claims. The CMA has since actively cracked down on the use of green claims, including through its review of claims in the fashion sector.

In March 2024, the CMA secured binding undertakings from three fashion retailers and published an open letter to the fashion sector. As we noted in our previous article here, the CMA has confirmed that it will continue its wider investigation into misleading advertising claims and will build on its Green Claims Code to include specific information relevant to the fashion sector. The Green Claims Code is not legally binding, but as it is based on the CPUT requirements, operators that adhere to it should be better placed to defend themselves if challenged by the CMA.

What do operators in the re-commerce sector need to consider when making green claims?

1. Environmental claims should be truthful and accurate

Advertising in the UK should be legal, decent, honest and truthful. Green claims should therefore only give consumers the impression that a product, service, brand or business is as “green” or “sustainable” as it really is. Broad, general, or absolute claims are more likely to be inaccurate or mislead consumers, so green claims should be qualified appropriately. Further, operators need to create internal processes to review claims regularly to ensure they remain accurate.

2. The basis of environmental claims should be clear and unambiguous

Green claims should be easy to understand by consumers. Therefore, scientific, or technical language should be avoided for a consumer audience, and general terms should be clarified. For example, generalisations such as a product being “recyclable” could be understood to mean it is fully recyclable, so it should be caveated appropriately if this is only applicable to a part of the product.

3. Do not omit or hide important information

Whilst a balance is to be struck when working with limited advertising space, the CMA has emphasised that businesses should not just cherry-pick the beneficial parts of a business. Any caveats or conditions with claims should be disclosed to consumers up front, as well as any other information that consumers need to make an informed choice. For example, the CMA has given the example of a logistics company stating that it is investing 10% more in electric vehicles. If the company does not disclose that it is also investing 40% more in diesel vehicles, this would be misleading. This is also important from a brand reputation perspective, to maintain trust with consumers.

4. Make fair and meaningful comparisons

When a business compares its products or services to a competitor's, the comparisons should be clear, current, and based on objective, like-for-like information that consumers can understand. For example, saying a product is “more sustainable” than another is likely unfair because the basis of the comparison is unclear.

5. Substantiate claims appropriately

Businesses need to support their green claims with credible and verifiable evidence, ideally from independent sources when possible. Claims are less likely to be misleading if the supporting evidence is publicly available and consumers can easily see where and how to verify these claims. Recent enforcement actions highlight the importance of having strong documentary evidence to back up green claims.

6. Consider the full lifecycle of products

When making environmental claims, businesses should always consider the total life cycle of a product or service, or of their overall activities, on the accuracy of their claims. This includes from sourcing, production, transportation, and use, through to disposal.

This does not mean that information about the full life cycle of a product or service must be included in every claim. However, businesses should consider what elements of the life cycle of a product or service are most likely to be of interest to consumers, and how they affect the accuracy of the claim. If claims are based on a specific part of a product’s life cycle, or part of a business’s activities, it should be clear which aspects are being referred to, and businesses should not focus on a relatively minor part of a product’s life cycle to suggest a product is greener than it is.

Next steps

Operators in the re-commerce sector, including peer-to-peer platforms and B2C resale retailers, must carefully follow the Green Claims Code and any related guidance it offers to comply with regulatory principles. The CMA has extensive powers to impose sanctions, from written warnings to criminal prosecution, and it is actively cracking down in this area. This applies to all advertised products and services in the re-commerce sector, from fashion items to resale services and fulfilment operations. Further guidance on how to navigate green claims without greenwashing can be found from the Advertising Standards Authority here.

Greenwashing is a hot topic in the EU too. The Green Claims Directive will compel companies to substantiate their environmental claims and create common criteria that consumers can check. This is set to complement recent updates to EU consumer protection law, which now bans generic environmental claims such as “eco-friendly", “green”, and “ecological” unless the trader is able to demonstrate recognised excellent environmental performance relevant to the claim.

If you would like to discuss green claims in the re-commerce sector further, please contact CMS. In the meantime, you can visit CMS’s interactive platform, CMS Green Globe, which provides updates on sustainability claims and greenwashing.

This article was written by CMS associate, Jessica Wilkinson, and Stuart Helmer, Of Counsel, UK Head of Advertising and Marketing. It was first published on CMS Law-Now on 14th June 2024. You can read the full article here.

CMS
About the author

CMS

With more than 70 offices in over 40 countries and 5,000+ lawyers worldwide, CMS offers deep local market understanding with a global perspective. They are focused on building strong relationships with clients, people, industry sectors and wider communities. As a future facing firm, CMS takes a bold, dynamic and agile approach to help clients of every size face the future with confidence. The firm has an immense depth of understanding of the sectors in which they operate. Its lawyers are genuine experts in their fields and are able to advise on current challenges as well as anticipate those on the horizon that are likely to shape the future. CMS aims to build a culture of trust, respect and support embracing all aspects of diversity and inclusion, leading the legal sector in social impact and sustainability. It strives to inspire, impact and support clients and people, helping them to maximize their potential and thrive.

Share "Navigating green claims without greenwashing" on

Related Videos